Skip to content
CBV360

Case 03 / creative practice

Sofia designs for another life.

An independent product designer wants a useful object that people can keep using after one part wears out. She tests that ambition on a small, non-electrical desk caddy before claiming any wider benefit.

Illustration of a modular object and alternative design pathsPortrait of Sofia, the fictional designer

Sofia, the product and the events below are fictional. This is a source-grounded design scenario, not a tested product, environmental claim or certification. Independent product-design review remains pending.

01 / CREATE

Ask what happens when a part fails.

Sofia notices that a cracked divider can make an otherwise useful desk caddy feel disposable. Her longer ambition is to build a design practice that makes repair a normal part of ownership. She does not assume that adding screws or calling a material “sustainable” will solve the problem.

She asks: Could a small desk caddy allow its most vulnerable part to be replaced by its owner without making the whole object harder to use or produce? She sketches a one-piece version, a modular version with a replaceable divider, and a service route where she repairs returned objects. She chooses the replaceable-divider question as a bounded first test, while recording who would need to supply a spare and instructions.

Output: a design brief with the likely failure, intended user, alternative approaches and assumptions to check.

Use the Create prompts ↗
02 / BUILD

Learn about the whole repair path.

The Ellen MacArthur Foundation’s Circular Design Guide helps Sofia look beyond the object to users, materials, replacement parts and the system that would keep it useful. She uses its circular-opportunities exercise to keep the intervention small. Its material-selection guidance makes her list what she knows and does not know about a candidate material, finish and end-of-use route.

  1. Talk with a few potential users about how they store items, what has broken before and whether they would try a simple repair.
  2. Sketch two joint options and a replacement instruction. Record tools, steps, time and what might be damaged during disassembly and reassembly.
  3. Compare material and finish options using supplier information; seek appropriate specialist input before making safety or environmental claims.

iFixit’s repairability criteria give her questions about access, disassembly, reassembly, manuals and parts. Its scoring system was made for devices, so she uses it as a prompt—not as a score for a desk caddy. She also checks the cost and practicality of actually providing spares.

Learning result: a material-and-repair assumptions sheet plus two testable concepts, not a declaration that the product is circular.

Find practical methods ↗
03 / VISUALIZE + VALIDATE

Make the repair visible and testable.

Sofia imagines a user replacing a damaged divider at home with a common tool and a spare ordered from her studio. She makes low-fidelity mock-ups, then a limited functional prototype. Before showing it, she writes three questions: can people understand the assembly, can they remove and reattach the divider without damage, and do they still like using the object?

In a planned small test, she would observe several people completing a normal storage task and then attempting the repair using the draft instructions. She would record completion, time, mistakes, damage, tool needs and comments, including negative reactions. She would compare the prototype with the original one-piece concept and ask a maker to review production effort and spare-part logistics. These are proposed measures, not results from an actual trial.

Decision rule: if the divider can be replaced but the joint fails ordinary use or spares are impractical, redesign before proceeding. If feedback supports the concept, run durability, material and production checks with qualified help. Do not infer lower environmental impact from repairability alone; that would require a defensible comparison.

Creative direction: Sofia has a reviewable next experiment and a stronger design question, not a finished circular product.

Plan a responsible test ↗

Source trail · checked 21 November 2026

The methods behind Sofia’s choices

These open sources guide the scenario. They do not prove that a fictional design reduces waste or meets a product standard.

VALIDATE · FEEDBACK

IDEO.org: Get feedback

Observe relevant users and invite candid reactions to the prototype.

The repairability source concerns electronic devices; Sofia borrows questions, not its score. Product and environmental claims would need separate evidence and applicable checks. Independent practitioner review is still open.

What the cycle makes possible

A repairable ambition with a testable first object.

A repair trial could lead Sofia to change this object and test again. If parts availability proves to be the harder problem, it could start a connected cycle around sourcing and service. The evidence will guide what she designs next.

See all journeys ↗